If you are an expert in X, and the popular understanding of X is X, you will end up having the exact same conversation about X every time. And so those are genes that show up as giving you a bump in your IQ in populations genetic studies. But you know what really has provided a massive survival advantage over the last few millenia of people clumping up together in cities? And autistic people have more health issues than non-autistic people do. corticalchauvinism. I was a bit of an outlier in my family, and didnt really find a peer group I fitted in with until university. I dont have time to go through all the links this morning but wanted to add some more studies. But her personal life is a mess. But the Gardner study also ceilings off at 90th percentile intelligence, so at this point Im not sure what to tell these people. As for my own personal experience, Ive found that people with high conceptual intelligence (as opposed to mathematical intelligence) tend to be more charismatic. Its highly unlikely for someone with either of those conditions to become the Director of the FBI. In sum, the heterogeneity of risk factors, brain impairments, and non-diagnostic symptoms in an ASD-defined sample blocks valid scientific inference. This study finds lower heritability than the usual estimates (which are around 80% to 90%; the authors are embarrassed by this, and in a later study suggest they might just have been bad at determining who in their sample did or didnt have autism. Quite a few trans women seem to be extremely masculine in their interests. Everyone else, enslaved or not, kept dying off working the fields. Intelligence may be very much the same way. Dammit, I was nodding along until you threw in sports-watching. Within our filter bubble, people have similar levels of status, so they can be smart but not charismatic or charismatic but not smart. If so, then the top-level geniuses may well have something else going on upstairs to enhance their intelligence, some other difference from the norms, that isnt part of the complex of IQ/autism risk genes. how could they recruit in such a way as to get a representative sample? If you keep stacking up genes that in isolation would improve your running speed, but that involve trade-offs or may have adverse interactions with each other by both modifying the same chemical pathway or something Eventually you have too many and things collapse. The damn thing has basically come true! In some sense, all autism has such-and-such characteristics studies are studying the way people like to define autism, and tell us nothing about any underlying disease process. focus on the denotations of words, not the emotional or social connotations. Yes, the biggest gains from any given exercise are to performing that specific exercise, but gaining strength that way still allows you to do other mostly unrelated motions that use the same muscle group that you couldnt have done without those exercises. So one model is that we should see two things happening at once, as a result of the assortative mating by IQ thats been going on for a couple generations now in the US: a. I suspect that this is the case. So I gave that fact to save others the effort to dig for it, while trying to give a subtle hint to you that it is better to include the finding. also didnt say anything about recruitment. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment More posts you may like. So far, this is still 70% wish-casting to 30% reality-aligned. While their exact numbers are doubtful, I think the overall finding that common familial genes are much more important than rare de novo mutations survives and is important. Now that Aspergers syndrome has been removed from the DSM, in favour of something understood by lay people as autism, Ive become autistic, along with a fair number of other geeks, nerds, etc. Our 2nd, 4th, and 5th children are not autistic, so parent age doesnt seem to have played a role in our case (though we were both relatively young even for our fifth, at 36 and 35.). Greg Cochran has a paper that discusses this and other IQ/genetic disease in Jews links here. Meanwhile, placing people on the spectrum equalizes access to resources, including insurance coverage. This would also neatly explain how a primarily genetic disease is becoming more prevalent people were always producing autistic children, they just werent surviving before. If you get much past that, all intelligible sound will cease and be replaced by a terrible noise that wasnt exhibited _anywhere_ prior in the range of the knob. Right, genes are NOT good or bad. (Always Sunny parodied this phenomenon with Mac, who only works out his glamour muscles.). The high end should stay the same, in much the way that the high end of human lifespan is only a little longer now than in 1800its just that a lot more people make it to 90 or 100 with modern medical care. Judith Harris discusses this in one of her books. Struggling to describe this. For example, they are not extremely aggressive, but tend to be gentle individuals. They would more easily get high IQ amongst Aspies, whom I dont consider Autistic. The autism epidemic may have been caused by assortative mating (people with subclinical autism marrying other people with subclinical autism producing children who are autistic) The sort of people that would do polygenic scoring for IQ are exactly the sort of people whose children might already be at risk for autism (high systemisers) Beware Simpsons Paradox. Plenty of people are both smarter and more charismatic than us. And an article by John Elder Robison pointing out that most of our data on autistic people come from children and the extreme cases. There are no other cases of autism diagnosed in the immediate family. At least part of the story is that there are at least three different causes of autism. The best civil servants get an extra allowance of weirdness points to allocate as necessary. Disguised in that almost is a very slight tendency for fathers to be unusually intelligent, plus a (statistically insignificant) tendency for them to be unusually unintelligent. I recall it because the lowest functioning children all had loser fathers. And this is a productive comment because? Indeed, higher survival rates over time might also explain why were seeing a real increase in the number of autistic children over time more of them are living long enough to be diagnosed with autism in the first place. This meant that theyd routinely turn them off. I dont think its quite that and even if it were, it would be really mysterious if double sickle cell genes caused more malaria! Of the 5 relatives, how many are males? Support Slate Star Codex on Patreon. 2016, p. 118), and there are many individually varied connections between brain and behavior (Kennedy et al. If you mean extraverted, no small number. The optimal value is at 10.0 (for example). While their exact numbers are doubtful, I think the overall finding that common familial genes are much more important than rare de novo mutations survives and is important. Autistic people being diagnosed with intellectual disabilities before theyre able to to talk and not really being undiagnosed when theyve demonstrated higher levels of ability is very much a thing. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-03-06/humanity-keeps-getting-smarter. But dont take my word for it, check out the excellent 2016 lit review by Waterhouse et al which concludes: No unitary ASD brain impairment or replicated unitary model of ASD brain impairment exists. Article I wrote about Sleep Apnea, Autism, and Neurodiversity. What do Norwegian founders with an international team on a mission to offer the equivalent of a Norwegian social safety net globally available as a membership. the kind of social impairment characteristic of bright but shy and social awkward people has much if anything to do at a deep level with the impairment experienced by non-verbal children with profound intellectual disabilities, despite the fact that we have built a social system that applies a similar label to both. Well, much debate here gets into the distinction between people with high functioning autism and Aspergers, due to a muddling at that end of the scale. The Flynn effect seems to be about raising the floor by building proper sewers and water supplies, eradicating parasites, vaccinating everyone against common childhood diseases, making sure nobody starves and also adding nutritional supplements to foods so brain development isnt stunted by deficiency diseases, eliminating heavy metals from the environment of small children, making sure everyone goes to school, etc. For such individuals, perfect pitch is almost always the indicator that highly refined processing is available in these areas of immediate reception of sound. My relatively uninformed opinion would be: what the mutations might be affecting in lower-order terms are some subtle parameters of prior mapping, or something like a lower threshold for whats considered to be sufficient fit for model validity, or what kinds of sensory inputs to give particular significance to. And her failure to understand social cues lets her be taken advantage of by lower-quality men, who have sexually abused her on multiple occasions. The reality is that weight training only increases strength in the motion of the lifts that you do. In Projections, and elsewhere, Deisseroth suggests that a major component of autism is as a bias or preference to information predictability, which anecdotally jives with what many people . n=1, but it was striking to watch my very smart middle kid go from being a near-outcast in his good Catholic school to a guy with lots of friends at his magnet school. The entire idea of a gene for intelligence is just as silly as a gene for running fast. There are genes which have lower-order effects, and intelligence or running are higher-order capabilities that emerge from the lower-order system in complex ways (indeed, theres probably several more layers than that.) Then why is there a genetic link? Like many DSM diagnoses it is a junkheap of often unrelated symptoms wrapped up in a single label for essentially politically reasons. This requires a strongly non-linear sensitivity to hyperparameters, which is unusual for the fitness w.r.t. In primary school, for a while we used to have daily spelling tests, where we had to spell ten words. no ones saying this only affects autistic people identified female at birth. So for example, bench is largely worthless if youre not pushing people away from you. The Effective Altruism newsletter provides monthly updates on the highest-impact ways to do good and help others. Score: 1. Perhaps something similar but more extreme is true of autism: maybe autistic people are more highly represented at both ends of the IQ distribution. This always seemed nonsensical to me, because muscle is muscle; if two people are equally large, it shouldnt matter whether they were born that way or got that way through exercise. ABA research, like autism research in general, suffers from an appalling lack of rigor. A link between Tay-Sachs gene and intelligence. Yes indeed. My crank theory is that autism, when looked at through the environmental toxins are causing Very Serious Problems lens, starts looking suspiciously like an environmentally induced phenotype, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_assimilation. Getting more education is strongly correlated with later childbearing / siring. (2005) reported that 50% of families visited their adult with autism at least weekly and an equal number of adults came weekly to visit at their mother's home. Because they survived due to wearing helmets, and we were only measuring *surviving* soldiers, helmets appeared to increase the number of head injuries, rather than decrease their severity. I mean, doesnt that just mean there are lots of hyper-parameters and you can push one set outside the optimal range without maxing out everything? This could be constructed as autistic behavior, but I dont buy it. (Which isnt the same as saying its bimodal; the distribution still peaks in the middle, but its wider and flatter.). I dont know their actual IQs, but Im very confident a lot of people in my bubble are nice, funny, enjoyable, sports-watching people with 99% intelligence. Take these away and you arrive at something that seems like an effortless confidence and freedom. They propose that the reason evolution favors autism genes is that they generally increase intelligence. Anyway, if the data were there, I would suggest an alternate explanation that a significant portion of gender dysphoria is socially mediated, and the autistic are isolated from the social phenomenon. So in that sense, maybe its just a phrasing problem. Some vaguely similar term like high functioning autism would be used. Maybe youre thinking of sickle cell anemia? As the authors put it: Because the ASD diagnosis is defined by just two symptoms from an individuals complete set of symptoms, an ASD-defined sample is widely over-inclusive, capturing many different lifelong conditions that can arise from a complex combination of multiple genetic and environmental factors (Dawson 2016, para. Social rituals are incredibly important though, humans are social animals. I view it as absolutely crucial that bright kids get to socialize with kids like them, and also that someone teaches them how to be a functional person. Blacks have an infant mortality rate more than twice as high as whites do. Most successful businessmen. Go up a level and you can mash a bunch of sequential notes on a piano with one left out of the middle and they can tell you the highest note, lowest note, and the one you left out. But if you pile on enough of the genes that increase IQ by increasing your head circumference, you will get a kid with such a huge head that his neck wont support it and his heart and lungs cant keep his giant brain in oxygenated blood, and hell die as a baby. The other two options I guess take effort, but Id say its effort that they enjoy putting in, because they enjoy the rewards (friendship, novel socializing, etc.). I used to live in the DC area and still work with the civil service in my current job. Autism, rationality and intelligence. There is another problem: Giftedness also increases empathy, which in the wrong environment can be a bad thing. 47.3k members in the slatestarcodex community. These are the people that make the Turing test invalid, youd think they were the chatbot. My vague mental model is that there are a bunch of different parameters that have to be within a certain range to get good performance from your brain. Naturally, things are getting worse. Maybe one bias from my statement is Im young, and many of my smart friends are also young. Autism prevalence increase, Deisseroth's "Projections", systems This makes a very strong auditory learner. You tell them that the study that tried to address that question suggests that they are between one point one and one point two times as likely; in other words, at least 83-90% of their chance to die in any given year is baseline. That, combined with intentional software creation can lead to more or less high functioning autists. For example, girls were much less likely to receive an Aspergers diagnosis than boys, and girls were more likely to be diagnosed at an older agea disparity that points to bias. Ah, that would explain the discrepancy. The latter are the Feynman types: Goofballs with a myriad of weird interests (Feynman was into playing the Bongo drums and the short lifed Soviet Republic Tannu Tuva, among other things). https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/05/07/5-httlpr-a-pointed-review/, https://sci-hub.tw/10.1176/appi.ajp.2018.18070881, Arizone State University Autism symptoms reduced nearly 50% two years after fecal transplant, The Economist More evidence that autism is linked to gut bacteria, Maybe Your Zoloft Stopped Working Because A Liver Fluke Tried To Turn Your Nth-Great-Grandmother Into A Zombie, https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s40489-016-0085-x.pdf, http://cepuk.org/unrecognised-facts/diagnostic-system-lacks-validity/, https://medicine.uiowa.edu/psychiatry/content/ui-research-suggests-huntingtons-disease-gene-also-vital-human-development-and-intelligence, https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2749054, https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/9/8/e029040.full. I really like this change. Pretending that people with autism diagnoses are typical of people with autism is useful when trying to treat the symptoms of autism; but ignoring less symptomatic people results in ineffective studies when trying to figure out causes and effects. Against autism as "extreme male brain"? : slatestarcodex They all share the same hunger for mathematics, and if you get to know those who seem normal on the surface, you find out that they have some interesting hobbies as well. Well, I think its certainly a reasonable possibility, which in my experience appears to be true, that beyond a certain point, intelligence either directly causes weirdness or is reliant upon it as a foundation. Brasserie Cambier - Croix, Hauts-de-France - Untappd This friend had been working for many years with Leroy Hood. Now there is a very strong effect towards their fathers being less intelligent than usual. Is there anything you can do in terms of testing or practice to reduce your risk? Just install an extension and when you buy something, people in poverty will get medicines, bed nets, or financial aid. I would expect a challenge, in testing the intelligence of Autistics. Dunno, but you dont need to know the exact structure of the genotype to phenotype map to check whether the assumption is empirically correct. I have always considered him more naturally gifted than me. Why do you think they arent sperging out about sportsball? But if you want to redefine incredible to mean the top 0.1 percent of the population, then yes, Bugmasters guess would be roughly accurate: Thered be approximately 1,250 people who were both incredibly smart and incredibly charismatic in the Western world, or maybe 1,500-2,000 if you assume a minor positive correlation between being intelligence and being socially adept. And rich people, on average, receive better medical care particularly rich white people. That seems like a poor methodology; I think it would be better to start with an unbiased sample of the general population and test them for both autism and IQ. And thus a little more involvement from the microglia in utero or during early childhood might lead to a more efficient neural configuration and a higher IQ, especially if the involvement is more concentrated in the brain regions with more of an evolutionarily enforced margin toward resilience/survival rather than cognitive performance in normal humans. Karpinksi et al. Humans have been selectively breeding themselves since the dawn of civilization, even if we werent consciously aware of it; reproductively speaking, the traits that are selected for in an organized society are bound to differ than those that wouldve been selected for in the wild. This can lead to bullying and social isolation, which in the long term can cause depression and the failure to learn social customs. Because they lacked the development of the auditory processing, it was very draining for them because it mostly came across as a large amount of noise. One solution is to view your family rather than your schoolmates as your peer group.
Wall Mounted Kitchen Taps Bunnings, Articles S
slatestarcodex autism 2023